Professional liability: Sharing risks with humans, not technology

Professional liability underwriters and risk managers are often asked how risk and professional liability changes for design firms using advanced digital technologies (such as generative design, DfMA (Design for Manufacturing & Assembly), VR/AR, BIM, Digital Twins, etc.). The simplest answer is that humans manage all technologies and the liability question and associated risks stop right there—regardless of the technology used. Professional liability insurance is about shared risks with humans, not technology, and the agreement to insure assumes that the insureds will exercise sound professional judgement in accordance with the standard of care no matter the technology and tools used to deliver those services.

While the design and construction industry pivots to delivering services more efficiently and effectively by adopting new tools, rest assured that the liability calculus remains the same. When someone files a claim or lawsuit against a design firm, liability in a courtroom will rest on how the design professional (the human) exercised professional judgment, measured against the standard of care and, if there’s evidence of negligence, whether that negligence caused harm and damages.

The question of risk is slightly different and more nuanced than the question of liability. Is a firm exposing itself to more risk by using transformative technologies to deliver professional services? The answer is that it depends. The risk exposure depends on the people using digital technologies: their competence, their quality controls, their communications skills, their abilities to document clearly expectations in contracts, and their service execution throughout the design and construction phase. Clearly, a design firm that maintains strong talent and complements that talent with advanced digital tools in the delivery of those services to communicate and document more effectively and efficiently with all project stakeholders will have a competitive advantage in the marketplace. Notably, those companies will also enjoy strong shared-risk relationships with professional liability insurers, not a small consideration in these economic times.



Victor and CNA work with the AIA Trust to offer AIA members quality risk management coverage through the AIA Trust Professional Liability Insurance Program, Business Owners Program, and Cyber Liability Insurance program to address the challenges that architects face today and in the future. 

This article was initially shared by Victor and can be found here.

You may also be interested in:

Embodied Carbon Reduction in the Built Environment

Earlier this year, the US passed the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022, with $369 billion in funding intended to cut climate pollution in half by 2030 (from 2005 levels). The private sector is also embracing capital-allocation strategies that take environmental, social, and governance (ESG) issues into account with their business practices. Over the next few…

Professional Liability Insurance: 2022 Trends

The AIA Trust together with the American Council of Engineering Companies (ACEC) and the National Society for Professional Engineers (NSPE) work annually to conduct an insurance carrier review and interview of professional liability trends and risk management issues.  Following is a summary of highlights for 2022 in addition to complimentary useful resources made available to…